How to Evaluate Snow Contracts and Protect Profit Margins - The Edge from the National Association of Landscape Professionals

We recently updated our Privacy Policy. By continuing to use this website, you acknowledge that our revised Privacy Policy applies.

How to Evaluate Snow Contracts and Protect Profit Margins

Photo: Brilar

Plenty of snow contracts can appear profitable on paper, but when the flakes start falling, you can quickly realize the actual work it calls for isn’t executable or efficient for your team.

“We’ve learned that bigger isn’t always better,” says Justin Cordes, senior director of Ryan Lawn & Tree’s Omaha branch. “Multiple locations, complicated scopes, excessive reporting requirements, different expectations at each site, or too many exceptions within an agreement can quickly create operational challenges and erode margin.”

As you move into this year’s snow season, pay attention to which properties consume more resources than expected and why.

Tracking Profitability by Property

When evaluating your snow contracts, compare revenue with the actual costs of servicing each property rather than relying on season-wide results.

“A good overall year can hide a handful of properties that lose money every winter,” says Larry Yaffa, CEO of Brilar, based in Farmington Hills, Michigan.

Cordes says they evaluate each snow account individually to see what it truly took to serve a property. They monitor aspects such as labor hours, salt usage, plow time, loader time, sidewalk crews, and other equipment utilization.

“From there, we compare the actual cost of servicing the account to the revenue and margin we generated,” Cordes says. “Were our margins where we expected them to be? Did certain events consistently require more labor or material than we originally estimated? Were there operational challenges with the property that added cost?”

Yaffa says if extended hours, nights or weekends aren’t identified ahead of time, you’ll end up servicing more than you priced. He says it’s also important to outline service expectations upfront; otherwise, you’ll end up delivering more than the job was estimated for.

“Scope creep can have a major impact as well,” Cordes says. “Over time, additional areas or expectations can get added that weren’t part of the original bid: extra walks, entrances, loading areas, return visits, or additional treatments. Individually, they may seem small, but over an entire winter they can really eat into the margin.”

Evaluate the Property’s Operational Fit

Even if a property aligns with your profit goals, you also need to listen to your production team’s feedback about the site.

“They often know before anyone else which properties are inefficient, difficult to service, or simply don’t fit your operation,” Cordes says.

Cordes encourages companies to be selective and understand what a good snow contract looks like for their specific operation.

“Not every piece of revenue is good revenue, and a contract that works well for one company may not make sense for another,” Cordes says.

When reviewing your production data, ask how efficiently you served the site. Properties that are sidewalk-heavy, difficult to access, have limited snow storage, require dedicated equipment, or simply don’t fit efficiently within your existing routes should all be evaluated closely.

“A well-priced property can still hurt your margin if it doesn’t fit your routes or requires inefficient deployment of labor and equipment,” Cordes says. “Sometimes improving snow margins is as much about choosing the right work as it is about raising prices.”

Review Your Liability Exposure

Another element to consider when reviewing your snow removal contracts is the liability of specific properties. Cordes says if a site creates unnecessary risk for their crews or equipment, that carries a lot of weight in the decision of whether to keep a client.

Photo: Brilar

Yaffa says they will review how many slip-and-fall claims or incident reports came from a particular property, whether the customer’s expectations match what the contract says, and whether the site layout or traffic has changed.

“A site can be profitable on paper and still be a bad fit if it carries more exposure than we’re being paid for,” Yaffa says.

Yaffa adds that some contracts can require a very high insurance umbrella for the size or type of property that they have.

“This could get very costly if you have to increase your umbrella policy,” Yaffa says.

Yaffa encourages companies to watch for indemnification and hold-harmless clauses, as one-sided language can push a property owner’s liability onto your business.

“Read the indemnification language as carefully as the price, because one claim can erase years of profit on an account,” Yaffa says. “Document everything, every visit. And don’t be afraid to walk away from a site where the risk is bigger than the check.”

Decide When to Reprice, Restructure or Walk Away

Once you’ve identified which snow contracts need attention, then you can determine the best path forward. In some cases, it simply calls for adjusting the pricing to the right level.  

“At renewal, we price off what the site actually consumed, not what we estimated when we bid it,” Yaffa says. “If a lot used more hours or product than budgeted, that shows up in the new number. We also average across several seasons rather than reacting to one heavy or light winter, so the customer gets a price that holds up over time, and we don’t chase the weather.”

Cordes says they take into account changes they expect for the following season, including salt and material pricing, subcontractor rates, labor costs, equipment costs, and any changes in the customer’s service expectations when raising prices.

In other cases, a specific service like shoveling walks or salting might be underpriced, which calls for restructuring a portion of the agreement.

“We’ve also become more intentional about identifying labor-heavy portions of a property, particularly sidewalks, and making sure those services are priced appropriately rather than allowing a profitable plowing operation to subsidize an unprofitable portion of the contract,” Cordes says.

However, there are some properties where raising the price or restructuring the agreement doesn’t solve the underlying problem.

Yaffa says they will walk away from a snow contract when the risk can’t be priced.

“If a customer wants zero-tolerance service but won’t pay for the salt and staffing that takes, or pushes back on documentation, or wants us to take on liability for conditions we don’t control, like drainage problems or refreezing from roof melt, we’ll walk away,” Yaffa says. “We’ll also walk when the relationship is no longer mutually beneficial.”

Cordes says if they consistently miss their margins, the production team provides negative feedback event after event or if the site requires an exorbitant amount of attention, they will move on from these clients. He says they focus on accounts where they can perform efficiently, meet the client’s expectations, take care of their people, and make a reasonable margin.

“Ultimately, choose the work that fits your operation, price it based on real data, clearly define expectations, and build relationships with clients who value the level of service you’re trying to provide,” Cordes says. “If you do those things consistently, the profitability tends to follow.”

Want to learn more? Join NALP for exclusive training, mentoring, and resources to grow your landscaping business.

Jill Odom

Jill Odom is the senior content manager for the National Association of Landscape Professionals.